Why Major League Soccer Needs a Promotion/Relegation System

 Major League Soccer (MLS) is the top-tier professional soccer league in the United States and Canada. Since its founding in 1993, the league has grown rapidly, expanding from ten teams in its first season to now 29 teams in 2023. Despite its impressive growth and success, there is one significant feature that MLS has yet to adopt: a promotion/relegation system. A promotion/relegation system would provide numerous benefits to MLS, including increased competition, fan engagement, and the ability to cultivate talent.




First and foremost, a promotion/relegation system would significantly increase the level of competition within MLS. As it stands, MLS teams are not incentivized to perform well unless they are competing for a playoff spot or a championship. However, in a promotion/relegation system, teams would be fighting for their place in the league. The threat of relegation would motivate teams to perform at their best in every game, leading to more exciting and competitive matches. Additionally, teams that are promoted from lower leagues would bring a new level of talent and competition to MLS, which would raise the overall quality of play.


Another benefit of a promotion/relegation system is increased fan engagement. One of the most exciting aspects of soccer in countries where promotion/relegation is in place is the battle for survival at the bottom of the table. Fans of teams in danger of relegation become incredibly invested in the outcome of each match, leading to higher attendance and more passionate support. Additionally, the chance for smaller teams to make their way into the top tier through promotion provides a sense of hope and excitement for fans, which further increases engagement.


Finally, a promotion/relegation system would provide MLS with the opportunity to cultivate talent in a way that is not currently possible. In a traditional American sports league, there is no incentive for teams at the bottom of the standings to play their young or unproven players. However, in a relegation battle, these players would be given more playing time, allowing them to develop and gain valuable experience. Additionally, teams in lower leagues would be motivated to invest in their youth academies and development systems in order to produce the best players possible. This would result in a higher overall level of talent in the league and a better chance for American and Canadian players to compete at the highest level of the sport.


I'm not sitting here saying that there are no obstacles to implementing a system like this. However, I believe that the numerous benefits outlined in this article significantly outweigh the obstacles to entry. A promotion/relegation system would increase the level of competition, deeply engage fans, and provide a new opportunity to cultivate youth talent. While there are logistical and financial challenges to implementing such a system, the potential benefits make it a worthwhile endeavor. MLS has already established itself as a major player in the world of soccer, and a promotion/relegation system would only serve to further solidify its position as a top-tier league.

Comments